Blog

How to Choose a CMMC Consultant: 10 Questions to Ask

Written by Travis Sands | Nov 16, 2026, 9:02:29 PM

Pick a CMMC consultant who will do the work with you, show you the evidence, and then step aside so an independent assessor can check it. The best test is ten plain questions about scope, deliverables, people and independence. If a firm can't answer them in writing, keep looking.

Here is what to ask, what good answers sound like, and the one rule that decides who can and can't assess you later.

Where does CMMC stand right now?

On July 13, 2026, the Department of War suspended the move to CMMC Phase II, which had been set for November 10, 2026. During the suspension, new requirements can only call for Level 1 (Self) or Level 2 (Self). As of November 16, 2026, no restart date has been announced.

What did not change: DFARS 252.204-7012, NIST SP 800-171, 72-hour incident reporting, SPRS scores and annual affirmations all still apply. So the job of a consultant today is to help you build a self-assessment score you can defend, and to get you ready for third-party assessment if and when it returns.

What should a CMMC consultant actually do for us?

A good consultant prepares you. That usually means:

  • A gap assessment against the 110 NIST SP 800-171 requirements
  • Your system security plan (SSP) and plan of action and milestones (POA&M)
  • Policies and procedures that match how you really work
  • Scoping: where CUI lives, which systems are in scope, and how to shrink that scope
  • A remediation plan your IT team or MSP can execute
  • Evidence collection and interview prep before assessment day

What a consultant should not do is assess and certify the same company it prepared. More on that below.

What questions should we ask before we sign?

Use this list on every firm you talk to. Ask for the answers in writing.

  1. Who will do the work? Get names and roles, not just the company's credentials. Ask what CMMC training or certifications each person holds.
  2. Have your people worked on real C3PAO assessments? Firms that have seen assessments know what assessors ask for. Firms that haven't are guessing.
  3. What do we get at the end? A list of deliverables: SSP, POA&M, policies, network and CUI data flow diagrams, an evidence index. "Guidance" is not a deliverable.
  4. How do you scope? A good answer starts with finding where your CUI is, before deciding which systems to protect.
  5. Who makes the technical changes? If your MSP owns the firewall and Microsoft 365, the consultant has to work with them. Ask how.
  6. How will you score us? They should use the DoD Assessment Methodology and show their work for every requirement.
  7. What happens to items we can't fix right away? Under 32 CFR 170.21, only some gaps can go on a POA&M, and they must be closed within 180 days. The consultant should know which ones.
  8. Will you help us affirm? A senior official at your company signs the SPRS affirmation. Your consultant should prepare that person, not sign for them.
  9. Are you independent of our assessor? Ask directly whether the firm or its people plan to take part in your certification assessment. The answer should be no.
  10. What does ongoing support look like? CMMC is not one-and-done. Ask how they help you keep the SSP, POA&M and evidence current between assessments.

Can the firm that prepares us also assess us?

No. The CMMC rule bars anyone who served as a consultant to prepare your organization from taking part in your Level 2 certification assessment for 3 years. It is in the Code of Professional Conduct requirements at 32 CFR 170.8(b)(17)(ii)(G).

That split protects you. An assessment by the same people who wrote your SSP is not an independent check, and it would not hold up.

Here is how the roles line up:

RoleWhat they doCan they certify you?
Consultant or RPOGap assessment, SSP, POA&M, policies, remediation plan, assessment prepNo
Your MSP or IT teamMakes the technical changes and runs day-to-day ITNo
C3PAOPerforms the Level 2 certification assessmentYes, if it did not prepare you
Your Affirming OfficialA senior official at your company who affirms compliance in SPRSAffirms only

FirstCall Federal is an authorized C3PAO. We assess organizations we did not prepare, and we never assess a client we've consulted for within the 3-year window. Our team is led by a Lead Certified CMMC Assessor who has worked on more than 30 C3PAO assessments, so we know what assessors look for.

What are the red flags?

  • "We'll get you certified." No consultant can promise certification. Only an independent C3PAO decides.
  • A template pack with your logo on it. Policies that don't match your systems fail at interview time.
  • No talk of scope. If nobody asks where your CUI is, the project is aimed at the wrong target.
  • No plan for your MSP. Documents that your IT provider has never seen won't match your environment.
  • A score with no evidence behind it. A high SPRS score you can't back up is a bigger risk than a lower one you can.

Should we use our MSP or a separate CMMC consultant?

Often both. Your MSP knows your systems and makes the changes. A compliance consultant writes the plan, the documents and the evidence trail, and keeps the two in sync. The question to settle up front is who owns what. If your MSP wants a compliance partner for its defense clients, see our MSP partner program.

What to do this quarter

  1. Pull your current SPRS score and the date of your last self-assessment.
  2. Shortlist two or three firms and send each the ten questions above.
  3. Check each firm and person in the Cyber AB Marketplace.
  4. Ask your MSP to join the scoping call.
  5. Pick the firm whose written answers are the most specific.

Common questions

What is a CMMC RPO?
A Registered Practitioner Organization (RPO, sometimes called a Registered Provider Organization) is a firm listed in the Cyber AB Marketplace that provides CMMC advisory and preparation services. RPOs prepare organizations. They do not perform certification assessments.

Can a C3PAO also be our consultant?
A C3PAO can offer consulting, but under 32 CFR 170.8(b)(17)(ii)(G) anyone who prepared you cannot take part in your Level 2 certification assessment for 3 years. Use different firms for preparation and assessment.

Do we still need a consultant while Phase II is suspended?
Level 2 (Self) assessments and SPRS affirmations are still required, and DoW has not said what assessment model follows the review. Many contractors use this time to make their score defensible before the rules change again.

How long does CMMC preparation take?
It depends on scope and how much is already in place. Ask each firm for a timeline built from your gap assessment, not a generic estimate.

Does FirstCall Federal assess or certify clients?
Yes. FirstCall Federal is an authorized C3PAO, so we perform Level 2 certification assessments. We assess organizations we did not prepare, and we never assess a client we've consulted for within the 3-year window.

Related reading

See where you stand before you call anyone

Answer a short set of questions and get a readiness snapshot to share with any firm you're vetting. Take the CMMC readiness self-assessment.

Sources: Department of War memorandums and CMMC Phase II suspension, July 13, 2026 (summarized by Crowell & Moring and NCMBC); 32 CFR 170.8(b)(17)(ii)(G) (Cornell LII); 32 CFR 170.21; Secureframe CMMC news tracker (latest entry Oct 1, 2026; no restart announced). Reviewed: November 16, 2026.